High birefringence, low loss, and flattened dispersion photonic crystal fiber for terahertz application*

Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 11604260) and the Outstanding Youth Science Fund of Xi’an University of Science and Technology, China (Grant No. 2019YQ3-10).

Wang Dou-Dou1, †, Mu Chang-Long1, Kong De-Peng2, Guo Chen-Yu1
College of Sciences, Xi’an University of Science and Technology, Xi’an 710054, China
The State Key Laboratory of Transient Optics and Photonics, Xi’an Institute of Optics and Precision Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Xi’an 710119, China

 

† Corresponding author. E-mail: wangdoudou@xust.edu.cn

Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 11604260) and the Outstanding Youth Science Fund of Xi’an University of Science and Technology, China (Grant No. 2019YQ3-10).

Abstract

A type of photonic crystal fiber based on Kagome lattice cladding and slot air holes in a rectangular core is investigated. Full vector finite element method is used to evaluate the modal and propagation properties of the designed fiber. High birefringence of 0.089 and low effective material loss of 0.055 cm−1 are obtained at 1 THz. The y-polarized fundamental mode of the designed fiber shows a flattened and near-zero dispersion of 0 ± 0.45 ps · THz−1 · cm−1 within a broad frequency range (0.5 THz–1.5 THz). Our results provide the theory basis for applications of the designed fiber in terahertz polarization maintaining systems.

1. Introduction

The electromagnetic wave located between the microwaves and infrared region is commonly defined as terahertz (THz) radiation with frequency domain from 0.1 THz to 10 THz. Recently, terahertz radiation has attracted significant attention due to its potential applications in sensing,[1] imaging,[2] time-domain spectroscopy,[3] pharmaceutical drug testing,[4] and communication,[5] etc. However, THz systems that rely on free-space and bulk optics to transport and manipulate the THz radiation are large and immobile, difficult to use and integrate with infrared and optical systems. In order to solve this problem, various THz waveguides have been reported, including metallic waveguides,[6] dielectric tubes,[7] Bragg fibers,[8] plastic ribbons,[9] photonic crystal fibers (PCFs),[1017] etc. Porous core PCFs have aroused the interest of the researchers widely for their low absorption loss, low dispersion, and high degree of design freedom. Besides, high birefringence can be achieved by breaking the symmetry of the core or cladding region of the porous core PCFs.

THz fiber with high birefringence has potential applications in THz systems, so a variety of highly birefringent THz PCFs have been investigated in recent years. Cho et al.[11] fabricated a plastic PCF that exhibits a birefringence of 0.021 at 0.3 THz. Atakaramians et al.[12] designed a porous fiber with slot air holes and obtained a birefringence of about 0.026 at 0.6 THz. Chen et al.[13] proposed a porous fiber with elliptical air-holes and obtained a high birefringence of 0.047 at 1.22 THz with the elliptical air-holes rotating at 30°. Hasan et al.[14] designed a spiral PCF with artificial asymmetry in the porous core and obtained a birefringence of 0.0483 at 1 THz.

Low loss and other characteristics, such as flattened and near-zero dispersion are necessary for practical applications of THz fibers, in addition to high birefringence. Wu et al.[15] proposed an oligoporous-core THz PCF with a birefringence of 0.03 and a low effective material loss of about 20%–40% of its bulk material loss. Habib et al.[16] presented a THz fiber with a rectangular core to realize a birefringence of 0.018 at 1 THz and a low flattened dispersion of 1.1 ± 0.02 ps · THz−1 · cm−1 in a frequency range of 0.8 THz–1.2 THz. Islam et al.[17] designed an oligoporous-core PCF with Kagome lattice cladding, which has a high birefringence of 0.079, low effective material loss of 0.05 cm−1 at 1 THz. Although the performances (i.e., the low loss, high birefringence, low/flattened dispersion) of THz PCFs have been improved individually or wholly, there is still much room for further improvement by designing fiber structures.

In this paper, a THz PCF with Kagome-structured cladding and rectangular core with slot air holes is designed. The designed PCF presents high birefringence, low loss and flattened near zero dispersion properties in a broad frequency range. The designed fiber structure has not been reported to the best of our knowledge, and it has potential applications in polarization-maintaining THz systems.

2. Fiber structure design

Cross section of the designed THz PCF is shown in Fig. 1. The Kagome-structured cladding (with lattice pitch Λ and Topas strut thickness t) is adopted as its compact design and extremely low confinement loss in a broad frequency range.[17] A rectangular core with five slot air holes is designed to induce the high birefringence and reduce the material absorption loss. L and W (L = 3Λ/2, ) donate the length and width of the rectangular core, respectively. The slot core air holes with equal intervals (center-to-center distance between two adjacent slot-core-holes is W/5) and different widths (h and 3h) are designed to improve birefringence and reduce material absorption loss.

Fig. 1. Cross section of designed PCF.

Material Topas is used as a background material in our design on account of its low material dispersion (with a constant refractive index of 1.5258) and relatively low material loss (rises at a rate of 0.36 cm−1/THz from 0.06 cm−1 at 0.4 THz) in a range of 0.1 THz–1.5 THz,[18] low water absorption (∼ 1/10 of the PMMA), and chemical resistance to common solvents.[19]

3. Results and discussion

The modal and propagation properties of the designed THz PCF are studied theoretically with the finite element method (FEM). Perfectly matched layer (PML) absorbing boundary condition is used to calculate the confinement loss.

As an important parameter for a polarization maintaining THz waveguide, the birefringence is defined as the absolute difference between the effective indexes of x- and y-polarized fundamental modes:[13]

where and are the real part of the effective refractive index for x- and y-polarized fundamental modes, respectively. From the definition point of view, birefringence can be increased by maximizing the difference between the mode field distributions of the x- and y-polarized fundamental modes.

The major transmission loss of PCF can be attributed to material absorption loss and confinement loss (CL). It is hard to fabricate a low loss THz fiber experimentally due to the fact that all materials except dry air have relatively high absorption coefficient for THz radiation. The material absorption loss of THz fiber can be reduced by maximizing the power fraction of the fundamental modes in air. The effective material loss (EML) of the fundamental modes, caused by material absorption, can be expressed as[20]

where ε0 and μ0 are the permittivity and permeability of the vacuum, respectively, nmat and αmat are the refractive index and bulk material absorption loss of Topas, respectively, E is the electric field component, Sz is the z-component of the Poynting vector.

The CL depends mainly on the number of cladding hole rings and core porosity, it represents the ability to restrict the light in the core. The CL can be calculated from the following expression[21]

in decibels per meter, where Im(neff) is the imaginary of the complex effective refractive index, f is the operating frequency, and c is the speed of light in vacuum.

Dispersion is also an important propagation property for THz waveguide as it degrades the signal in broadband or long distance transmission. Flattened and near-zero dispersion is necessary for the effective transmission of broadband THz waves. Firstly, it is necessary to ensure single mode propagation in order to reduce intermodal dispersion. The single mode condition for index guiding PCF can be determined by the normalized frequency expressed by the V-parameter[13]

where r is the radius of the fiber core (regarded as L/2 and W/2 for the x- and y-polarized fundamental modes, respectively), nco and ncl are the effective refractive indexes of the core and cladding, respectively. We evaluate the single mode condition with nco = neff, and ncl is taken as 1 due to the high air fraction of the cladding for the designed PCF. When the fiber operates in single mode condition, the dispersion can be attributed to material dispersion and waveguide dispersion. Material dispersion of the designed fiber can be neglected due to the fact that the background material Topas has a constant refractive index in a range of 0.1 THz–1.5 THz, so the dispersion is mainly caused by waveguide dispersion. In the THz region, group-velocity dispersion (GVD) can be calculated from the following equation[21]
where ω = 2π f.

Different core structures have been studied in order to obtain high birefringence. We find that the core structure with different slot air hole widths (defined as core 1) can introduce higher birefringence than the one with equal slot air hole width (defined as core 2) although their porosities are equal as shown in Fig. 2. Therefore, core 1 is adopted in the following study.

Fig. 2. Plots of birefringence versus frequency for two different core structures and mode profiles of the (i) x- and (ii) y-polarized fundamental modes at 1 THz (Λ = 200 μm, t = 0.015Λ, core porosity = 55%).

Figures 2(i) and 2(ii) are the mode profiles (power flow) of the x- and y-polarized fundamental modes for the designed PCF at 1 THz, respectively. It can be found that both the x- and y-polarized fundamental modes are well confined in the core region, but the former has better confinement (lower CL) and the latter has higher power fraction distributed in the slot core air hole (lower EML). The large difference between the x- and y-polarized fundamental mode profiles is due to the breaking of six-fold symmetry in the core.

Scalability dependence of the birefringence and EML have been studied in order to obtain the optimal structure parameters. Figure 3 shows the variation of birefringence and EML with respect to lattice pitch. It can be found that EML for both the x-polarized (x-pol) and y-polarized (y-pol) fundamental modes increases with lattice pitch increasing. This can be explained by the fact that larger lattice pitch means larger core and electromagnetic waves interact greatly with the material Topas, thus the EML increases. What is more, the EML of y-polarized fundamental mode is lower than that of the x-polarized fundamental mode, which is inconsistent with the mode field distribution as shown in Fig. 2. However, birefringence has a maximum value when the lattice pitch is 300 μm, which equals the guided wavelength. Considering a tradeoff between high birefringence and low EML, the value of Λ is fixed at 200 μm for the following study.

Fig. 3. Birefringence and EML versus lattice pitch at 1 THz (t = 0.015Λ, core porosity = 55%).

For realistic PCFs, the guided modes are inherently leaky as a result of the finite number of cladding hole rings, and confinement loss occurs inevitably. However, transmission loss of THz PCF is mainly derived from material absorption loss rather than confinement loss, especially for the PCF with Kagome lattice cladding. In order to make it flexible and compact, the THz fiber should be as thin as possible, i.e., the cladding hole rings should be as few as possible. Figure 4 shows the variation of birefringence, EML and CL with cladding hole ring number. It can be found that birefringence and EML have little change, although CL decreases dramatically with the cladding hole ring number increasing. Even two rings of cladding holes can obtain a negligible CL compared with the EML. So two rings of cladding hole structure are both adopted for the designed fiber.

Fig. 4. Birefringence and loss (EML and CL) versus cladding hole ring number at 1 THz, with inset showing magnified variation trend of CL (Λ = 200 μm, t = 0.015Λ, core porosity = 55%).

For an index guiding porous-core PCF, the material absorption loss can be reduced by maximizing the power fraction of the fundamental modes in air, which is closely related to the core porosity. Figure 5 shows the variation of birefringence and EML with core porosity in a range from 20% to 55% which is the maximum value for the designed core structure. It can be seen that the EML decreases linearly with the core porosity increasing. The variation of birefringence with core porosity is relatively small although it has a maximum value when the core porosity is around 40%. So the core porosity of 55% is adopted as an optimal structural parameter due to its low EML.

Fig. 5. Plot of birefringence and EML versus core porosity at 1 THz (Λ = 200 μm, t = 0.015Λ).

For Kagome-structured PCFs that may be fabricated by the stack-and-drawing, extrusion and even the flexible and accurate 3D printing technique, the relative strut-thickness (t/Λ) is also an important parameter that can affect propagation properties of the fiber.[2225] Figure 6 shows the variation of birefringence and EML with t/Λ for the designed THz fiber. It can be seen that birefringence decreases, the EML of y-polarized fundamental mode increases and the EML of x-polarized fundamental mode has little change with the increase of relative strut-thickness. Therefore, the relative strut-thickness should be as small as possible in order to achieve a high birefringence and a low EML. So a small relative strut-thickness t/Λ = 1.5% that has been experimentally reported[22] is adopted for the designed fiber.

Fig. 6. Plot of birefringence and EML versus relative strut thickness at 1 THz (Λ = 200 μm, core porosity = 55%).

By comparing Figs. 36, the conclusions are obtained as follows.

(i) The structural parameter dependence of birefringence and loss are different and even conflicting with each other as a result of their different origins.

(ii) Birefringences are of the same order of magnitude (10−2) although their variations with structural parameters (lattice pitch, cladding hole ring number, core porosity and relative strut thickness) are different. However, the variations of EML with structural parameters are relatively dramatic (from 0.04 cm−1 to 0.25 cm−1). So the structural parameters with lower loss are adopted rather than the ones with higher birefringence when they are conflicting with each other (as shown in Fig. 5).

(iii) Considering a tradeoff between high birefringence and low EML, the structural parameters with Λ = 200 μm, rings = 2, core porosity = 55% and t/Λ = 1.5% are adopted for the optimal THz PCF.

The V-parameter and dispersion characteristics of the designed optimum THz PCF are shown in Figs. 7(a) and 7(b), respectively. It is observed that the y polarization operates in single mode condition over the whole operating frequency spectrum, while the x polarization operates in single mode condition when the frequency is less than 1.17 THz. It can be seen that both the x- and y-polarized fundamental modes have low and flat dispersion within its single mode operating frequency spectrum. Especially the dispersion value of y-polarized fundamental mode is 0 ± 0.45 ps · THz−1 · cm−1 over a wide frequency range (0.5 THz–1.5 THz), which can be regarded as an ultra-flattened and near-zero dispersion.

Fig. 7. (a) V-parameter and (b) dispersion versus frequency of the fundamental modes for the optimized THz PCF.

The propagation properties of the designed THz PCF are compared with the recently reported PCF’s as listed in Table 1. It can be seen that the designed THz PCF shows improved propagation properties, i.e., higher birefringence, lower EML, ultra-flattened, and near-zero dispersion over a wider frequency range individually or wholly than the ever reported THz PCFs.

Table 1.

Comparison of propagation properties between designed THz PCF and other PCF’s.

.

It is necessary to discuss the fabrication possibilities of our proposed THz PCF for its practical implementation. There are many ways to fabricate the polymer-based PCFs compared with silica-based ones. Beside the stacking-and-drawing of capillaries, which is suitable for making PCFs with circular air holes arranged in triangular lattice, the extrusion, casting, molding, and drilling have been used successfully to made polymer PCFs with various complex and asymmetrical structures.[28] Moreover, the most recently developed 3D printing technique has been used to produced THz waveguides with complicated and small features, and the most advanced laser-based 3D printing techniques can realize a printing resolution of the order of micrometer in x and y dimensions.[29,30] Kagome lattice PCF and porous core PCF with non-circular slot air holes are fabricated successfully by using the stack-and-draw, 3D printing, extrusion techniques, etc.[23,31,32]

The structure of our proposed THz PCF with Kagome lattice cladding and slot air holes is relatively simple and robust compared with the PCFs operating in the telecommunication range, and the fabrication possibility is considered during the structural parameter optimization. So, it is possible to fabricate the designed THz PCF by using or combining the existing techniques, such as drawing from a 3D-printed preform.[33] In our previous papers, experimental investigations have been carried out for the fabrication of polymer-based PCFs.[34,35] The designed THz PCF in this paper will be fabricated in our consequent researches.

4. Conclusions

An improved Kagome PCF with slot air holes in a rectangular core is designed for the transmission of THz waves. Structural parameter dependence of the propagation properties such as birefringence, material absorption loss (effective modal loss), confinement loss and dispersion are numerically investigated by using the full-vector FEM. The simulation results indicate that even two rings of cladding holes can obtain a negligible confinement loss. Ultra high birefringence of 0.089 and low effective material absorption loss of 0.055 cm−1 are obtained at 1 THz for the optimized fiber structure. Besides, the y-polarized fundamental mode shows an ultra-flattened and near-zero dispersion of 0 ± 0.45 ps · THz−1 · cm−1 over 0.5 THz–1.5 THz. The designed THz PCF shows improved propagation properties compared with the recent reported PCF’s and its structure is relatively simple and manufacturable. Thus, the designed Kagome PCF has potential applications in fields of THz communication and polarization maintaining systems.

Reference
[1] Yu Y Y Li X Y He K P Sun B 2016 Chin. Phys. 25 028703
[2] Wang Y Ren Y Chen L Song C Li C Zhang C Xu D Yao J 2018 Chin. Phys. 27 114204
[3] Withayachumnankul W Fischer B M Lin H Abbott D 2008 J. Opt. Soc. Am. 25 1059
[4] Strachan C J Taday P F Newnham D A Gordon K C Zeitler J A Pepper M Rades T 2005 J. Pharm. Sci. 94 837
[5] Wang M Wang J F Wu Q Y Huang Y X 2014 Acta Phys. Sin. 63 154101 in Chinese
[6] Wang K Mittleman D M 2004 Nature 432 376
[7] Bowden B Harrington J A Mitrofanov O 2007 Opt. Lett. 32 2945
[8] Skorobogatiy M Dupuis A 2007 Appl. Phys. Lett. 90 113514
[9] Mendis R Grischkowsky D 2000 J. Appl. Phys. 88 4449
[10] Wang J L Yao J Q Chen H M Bing P B Li Z Y Zhong K 2011 Acta Phys. Sin. 60 104219 in Chinese
[11] Cho M Kim J Park H Han Y Moon K Jung E Han H 2008 Opt. Express 16 7
[12] Atakaramians S Shahraam A V Fischer B M Abbott D Monro T M 2009 Opt. Commun. 282 36
[13] Chen N Liang J Ren L 2013 Appl. Opt. 52 5297
[14] Hasan M R Anower M S Islam M A Razzak S M A 2016 Appl. Opt. 55 4145
[15] Wu Z Shi Z Xia H Zhou X Deng Q Huang J Jiang X Wu W 2016 IEEE Photon. J. 8 4502711
[16] Habib M A Anower M S Hasan M R 2018 Opt. Commun. 423 140
[17] Islam M S Sultana J Dinovitser A Ng W H Abbott D 2018 Opt. Commun. 413 242
[18] Nielsen K Rasmussen H K Adam A J Planken P C Bang O Jepsen P U 2009 Opt. Express 17 8592
[19] Khanarian G 2001 Opt. Eng. 40 1024
[20] Ung B Mazhorova A Dupuis A Rozé M Skorobogatiy M 2011 Opt. Express 19 B848
[21] Liang J Ren L Chen N Zhou C 2013 Opt. Commun. 295 257
[22] Argyros A Pla J 2007 Opt. Express 15 7713
[23] Couny F Benabid F Light P S 2006 Opt. Lett. 31 3574
[24] Wang Y Y Wheeler N V Couny F Roberts P J Benabid F 2011 Opt. Lett. 36 669
[25] Anthony J Leonhardt R Leonsaval S Argyros A 2011 Opt. Express 19 18470
[26] Luo J Chen S Qu H Su Z Li L Tian F 2018 J. Lightwave Technol. 36 3242
[27] Kawsar A Sawrab C Kumar P B Md S I Shuvo S Md I I Sayed A 2017 Appl. Opt. 56 3477
[28] Large M C J Ponrathnam S Argyros A Bassett I M Punjari N S Cox F Lwin R Barton G W Van E M A 2006 Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. 446 219
[29] Van P L D Gorecki J Numkam F E Apostolopoulos V Poletti F 2018 Appl. Opt. 57 3953
[30] Li J Nallappan K Guerboukha H Skorobogatiy M 2017 Opt. Express 25 4126
[31] Yang J Zhao J Gong C Tian H Sun L Chen P Lin L Liu W 2016 Opt. Express 24 22454
[32] Atakaramians S Afshar V S Ebendorff-Heidepriem H Nagel M Fischer B M Abbott D Monro T M 2009 Opt. Express 17 14053
[33] Cook K Canning J Leon-Saval S Reid Z Hossain M A Comatti J Luo Y Peng G 2015 Opt. Lett. 40 3966
[34] Kong D P Wang L L 2009 Opt. Lett. 34 2435
[35] Chen Q Kong D P Miao J He X Y Zhang J Wang L L 2017 Acta Phot. Sin. 46 0406001 in Chinese